Ever since the music streaming service Spotify was launched in 2008, it has been referred to as a model for an ongoing transformation of the media industries. Dozens of other technology startups have promised to deliver a Spotify for books, a Spotify for movies, a Spotify for journalism or even a Spotify for art. Yet, most attempts to replicate the model has actually failed. Analyzing a large body of Swedish and US news articles from 2008-2018, this article demonstrates how the metaphor of Spotify has been filled with very different meaning. Not only has the early promises of relying on advertising to make consumption free but legal been discarded, in favor of subscription-based models. Another major trend in the development of streaming services, including Spotify, has been the shift toward curation and algorithmic recommendation systems, which has added new associations to the metaphor or a Spotify for x.