We have studied the stability of C₅₉ anions as a function of time, from their formation on femtosecond timescales to their stabilization on second timescales and beyond, using a combination of theory and experiments. The C^-₅₉ fragments were produced in collisions between C₆₀ fullerene anions and neutral helium gas at a velocity of 90 km s⁻¹ (corresponding to a collision energy of 166 eV in the center-of-mass frame). The fragments were then stored in a cryogenic ion beam storage ring at the DESIREE facility, where they were followed for up to 1 minute. Classical molecular dynamics simulations were used to determine the reaction cross section and the excitation energy distributions of the products formed in these collisions. We find that about 15% of the C^-₅₉ ions initially stored in the ring are intact after about 100 ms and that this population then remains intact indefinitely. This means that C₆₀ fullerenes exposed to energetic atoms and ions, such as stellar winds and shock waves, will produce stable, highly reactive products, like C₅₉, that are fed into interstellar chemical reaction networks.