There are several difficulties when experimentally determined reaction mechanisms are applied from model systems to real catalysis. Besides the infamous pressure and material gaps, it is sometimes necessary to consider impurities in the real reactant feedstock that can act as promoters or catalyst poisons and alter the reaction path. In this study, the effect of sulfur on the dehydrogenation of naphthalene on Ni(111) is investigated by using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and scanning tunneling microscopy. Sulfur induces a (5√3 × 2) surface reconstruction, as previously reported in the literature. The sulfur does not have a strong effect on the dehydrogenation temperature of naphthalene. However, the presence of sulfur leads to a preferred formation of carbidic over graphitic carbon and a strong inhibition of carbon diffusion into the nickel bulk, which is one of the steps of destructive whisker carbon formation described in the catalysis literature.