User experience, which encompasses users’ feelings and perceptions, is regarded as a key element in the evaluation of recommender systems. The existing literature extensively works on recommendation generation strategies with focus on the accuracy by considering objective aspects of the system. Although some of the current works considered subjective aspects of the recommendation systems from a user-centric perspective to evaluate the recommender system, however, a comprehensive analysis that could investigate factors to improve user experience was of limited focus. In this paper, we propose a methodology that provides a comprehensive multi-perspective analysis of a social-aware fashion recommender system and analyses the impact of user’s personal attributes and profiles on their experiences in various aspects of system use. A user study was conducted to realize the proposed methodology. The obtained insights highlighted that user experiences vary not only from the perspective of using a recommender system but also by varying their personal attributes (age, gender, hobby) and profiles.