Wania and McLachlan (1) continue a discussion about the work of the Stockholm Convention (SC) on Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs). This is useful because some of the issues raised surrounding the implementation of the SC warrant concerted action to safeguard the effectiveness of the SC. However, several of their statements are unsubstantiated or factually incorrect and could mislead the discussion about the future work of the SC. Here, we first respond to some of their general statements about the functioning of the SC and then to their specific criticism of the nomination of UV-328.
According to the authors, “a large increase in the number of chemicals that fulfill the screening requirements could lead to a considerable expansion in the number of chemicals being eligible for nomination and listing.” They see this as a problem, primarily because the capacity of countries to implement SC decisions may be exceeded. However, contrary to the authors’ insinuation that a high number of nominations is a problem, the nominations show that the SC works well and addresses exactly the concern for which it was established, namely to protect human health and the environment from POPs. If there is a concern about too high a burden from implementing the SC, the logical response is to strengthen the implementation process, not to throttle the nomination process.