Given rising antiimmigrant sentiment in the United States, it is increasingly important to further investigate which psychological factors may facilitate helping toward immigrants. In two studies with White Americans (total N = 1,139), we investigated whether (and when) two positive emotions—group-based gratitude and group-based pride—influence benevolent and activism support toward immigrants in the United States. Although previous research on individual-level gratitude and pride suggests that they are distinct emotions, at the group-level, we find that among White Americans, national gratitude and pride clustered together and were statistically indistinguishable. Importantly, this combination of American gratitude-plus-pride had differential effects on helping toward immigrants, depending on two key factors: Political orientation of the perceiver, and the type of support rendered. Among conservatives and moderates, American gratitude-plus-pride was predictive of increased benevolent support. However among liberals, it was related to decreased activism support. Our findings suggest that the impact of group-based gratitude and pride on helping toward immigrants is complex, and contingent upon preexisting dispositions.