Spela rollen: Rollen konstnärlig ledare som relationell och performativ konstruktion
2026 (Swedish)Doctoral thesis, monograph (Other academic)Alternative title
Playing the role : Artistic leadership as a relational and performative construction (English)
Abstract [en]
Artistic leadership in theatre is commonly understood through the figure of the individual artistic leader: the charismatic artist, visionary director, or authoritative theatre director. My dissertation challenges this individual-centred understanding by examining how the role of the artistic leader is collectively produced, negotiated, and transformed within theatre organisations. I investigate how the role emerges as a relational and performative construction in the professional collective of Swedish institutional theatre.
To explore this, I adopt a dual epistemology, grounding the dissertation's knowledge claims in both leadership theory and artistic practice. Situated at the intersection of critical leadership studies, relational leadership theory, performativity theory, and research on theatre organisations, the study draws on Judith Butler's conceptualisation of performativity. Organisational roles and identities are understood not as pre-existing properties of individuals, but as effects of repeated, socially intelligible practices. The artistic leader is neither simply an autonomous subject nor merely the occupant of a formal position. Instead, the role is constituted through interactions, expectations, narratives, power relations, and embodied performances involving the leader and the organisational collective.
Empirically, the dissertation is based on fieldwork with theatre professionals in Sweden. To generate the empirical material, I developed an analogue game, Fan ska vara teaterdirektör! [Damn the life of a theatre director!]. The game invites participants to collectively recall, invent, negotiate, and share anecdotes concerning the artistic leadership role. I treat these anecdotal narratives not as representations of verifiable events, but as performative practices through which possible versions of artistic leadership are made intelligible. The game thereby functions both as a research setting and as a methodological device for examining how participants collectively construct meaning around leadership.
The analysis shows that the artistic leader is constituted through a shifting and contradictory set of expectations. The role is imagined as both enabling and threatening, protective and manipulative, visionary and irresponsible, present and absent. These contradictions are produced and reproduced through collective practices of storytelling, interpretation, recognition, distancing, and exclusion. Gendered, embodied, spatial, and affective dimensions shape the boundaries of legitimacy within the role, and anecdotal practices may both challenge and sustain dominant leadership imaginaries.
The dissertation contributes to critical and relational leadership studies by shifting analytical attention from the individual leader to the collective processes through which leadership roles become possible and intelligible. I extend Butler's performativity theory in leadership research by foregrounding intelligibility as a key mechanism through which certain versions of artistic leadership become thinkable. Methodologically, I demonstrate how a game can create a performative, material, and reflexive setting for qualitative inquiry. More broadly, I argue that changing problematic leadership practices in theatre requires more than replacing individual leaders or formalising structures. It also requires critical examination of the collective narratives, expectations, and practices through which the artistic leader is brought into being.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
Stockholm: Företagsekonomiska institutionen, Stockholms universitet , 2026. , p. 369
Keywords [en]
artistic leadership, theatre organisations, relational leadership, Judith Butler, performativity, intelligibility, anecdotes, gamebased method, data generation through gaming
Keywords [sv]
konstnärligt ledarskap, teaterorganisationer, relationella ledarskapsstudier, Judith Butler, performativitet, intelligibilitet, anekdoter, spel som metod, datagenerering genom spelande
National Category
Business Administration
Research subject
Business Administration
Identifiers
URN: urn:nbn:se:su:diva-260498ISBN: 978-91-8107-757-5 (print)ISBN: 978-91-8107-758-2 (electronic)OAI: oai:DiVA.org:su-260498DiVA, id: diva2:2107976
Public defence
2026-11-20, Hörsal 2, Hus 2, Albanovägen 18, Stockholm, 13:00 (Swedish)
Opponent
Supervisors
2026-10-272026-10-052026-10-21Bibliographically approved