We investigated soil metagenomes as potential sources of robust indicators of soil quality across three locations in Finland with varying crops and soil types. Metagenome sequences were categorized into rRNA operational taxonomic units and InterPro entries, collectively referred to as soil microbiota features. Even though no specific taxa or functional categories emerged as suitable indicators of soil quality, the numbers of proportional features and proportional feature pairs were higher in high-crop-yield soils compared to low-crop-yield soils. A similar trend was observed in amplicon sequencing datasets from potato fields in China and USA. This crop yield associated difference in proportionality was hypothesized to be linked with differences in the amount of relic DNA. Analyzing an amplicon sequencing dataset of total DNA extracts alongside extracts from which relic DNA had been removed suggested that proportionality was obscured by the presence of relic DNA, providing indirect evidence that the proportionality differences between high- and low-yield soils were associated with differences in soil relic DNA content.