Co-producing climate services has been proposed as a way to make climate services more usable by aligning scientific analysis with decision contexts, institutional needs, and practitioner knowledge. Yet the benefits of co-production are often assumed rather than evaluated, particularly in relation to how process design shapes the final product. This paper examines the co-production of New York City's first Flood Vulnerability Index (NYC FVI), developed by researchers and city agency stakeholders to support flood adaptation planning. Through a structured co-reflection with members of the NYC FVI core team, we identify how co-production process principles and product characteristics shaped the NYC FVI's development and perceived usability. Results show how participants perceived that the principles of flexibility, collaboration, and decision orientation helped the team negotiate methodological choices and improve the tool's institutional fit. At the same time, participants identified trade-offs related to timeliness, inclusiveness, continuity, and post-release learning. Rather than treating co-production as a guarantee of uptake, this study shows how a structured co-reflection can make visible the choices, constraints, and stewardship needs that shape the usability of co-produced urban adaptation climate services.