This study questions the traditional view of sacrifices in hero-cults during the Archaic to the early Hellenistic periods (c. 700-300 BC) as consisting mainly in holocausts, rituals focusing on the blood of the animal victim and the presentation of meals, and rarely in thysia sacrifices followed by collective dining.
The work is divided into three parts. The first part focuses on the terms eschara, escharon, bothros, enagizein, enagisma, enagismos and enagisterion, which have been considered as being characteristic for hero-cults and marking them as distinct from the cult of the gods and linked to the cult of the dead. The study of the use and meaning of these terms shows that a connection with heroes can rarely be established before the Roman period and mainly so in the Byzantine lexicographers and in the scholia, the information of which has generally been considered as valid also for earlier periods.
The second part is an analysis of the epigraphical and literary evidence for sacrifices to heroes based exclusively on sources from the Archaic to the early Hellenistic periods. Contrary to the traditional notion, the main ritual in hero-cults during this period was a sacrifice in which the worshippers consumed the meat from the animal victim. The thysia could be modified by the offering of prepared meals (theoxenia), a ritual that also existed separately from thysia. A particular handling of the animal’s blood at a thysia or a holocaust, at which the whole victim was destroyed, can rarely be documented and these two kinds of rituals must be considered as marginal features in hero-cults.
In the third part, the ritual pattern of hero-cults is compared with the use of similar rituals both in the cult of the gods and in the cult of the dead in order to define the place and function of hero-cults within a wider context. Since the main kind of sacrifice in hero-cults was a thysia, a ritual that was intimately connected with the social structure of society, the heroes must have fulfilled the same role as the gods within the Greek religious system. The rituals considered as linking the heroes with the dead (holocausts, blood rituals and offerings of meals) can be found also in the cult of the gods or belong to the category heilige Handlungen (rituals performed as a response to a particular situation and not having any divine recipient). When used in hero-cults, holocausts and blood rituals can often be connected with a particular purpose of the sacrifice on that occasion or a desire to recognize in ritual a certain side of the character of the hero receiving the sacrifice. The fact that the heroes were dead seems to have been of little significance for the sacrificial rituals and it is questionable whether the rituals of hero-cults are to be considered as originating in the cult of the dead.